VISTA·RESEARCH™
How it worksThe LibraryResearchHeritageAboutTalk to the Desk
Hypothesis · Planet Fitness and the Black Card

The Price of the Thing Most People Take

By Russ W. Rosenzweig · Vista Research · 15 November 2026 · Why I write with AI

Colleen Keating is the CEO of Planet Fitness, a chain of low-price gyms. On its quarterly results call of November 6, 2025, she told investors what had happened in the past when the company raised the price of its premium membership, the Black Card. For a while, fewer of the people who joined chose it. Just as many people joined. "So taking Black Card pricing in the past was not a headwind to join volume," she said. On the same call she announced the next increase, from $24.99 a month to $29.99.

Six months later, on May 7, 2026, she paused its national rollout. "Based on our experience, price increases create a near-term headwind to member joins." The shares had closed at $63.96 the day before. They closed that day at $44.01, down 31.19 percent. The company cut the year's sales forecast that same day.

The idea originated on October 26, 2026, with a securities complaint filed that July in federal court in New Hampshire, Matsunaga v. Planet Fitness, Inc. I read new complaints for fun. They come with my day job at Round Table Group, which helps trial lawyers find expert witnesses, and the habit has done nothing for my evenings. The complaint puts a legal question to a court, and we take no view of it. It sent me to the two calls with a business question. My first thought was that one of those sentences had to be wrong.

I no longer think so. Our hypothesis, and it is only that, is that both can be true, because something changed after the history was made. In March 2025 Planet Fitness ran a national campaign called Black Card First Month Free. That was before both calls. But every Black Card increase on record, in 2017, 2019 and 2022, came before it. A free first month may have turned the premium card from the thing members trade up to into the door beginners come in through. If it did, the company's own history is a poor guide to a $5 increase.

Later on the May call, answering an analyst, Ms. Keating described the earlier increases: "in the past where we've taken a lift in Black Card pricing, we've seen a slight headwind on joins, certainly a diminution on the penetration, but it builds back over time." Neither that account nor the November one describes a large loss of joins. So the question is less whether a higher Black Card price costs joins than how many this one would cost. And did the free month change which customers would walk away at $29.99?

That matters to anyone who owns the stock. Two thirds of the chain's 21.5 million members hold the Black Card. In May the company cut its 2026 forecast for growth in same club sales, the dues billed at clubs open more than a year, to about 1 percent. It had been 4 to 5 percent. By its own estimate, the pause was about 1.5 points of that cut.

We cannot settle the question from outside the company. So we weigh the rival explanations, name who holds the evidence, and freeze a test: we write down now what result would count for each reading. Our own odds come later, and they do not flatter us. They may never be scored at all. On November 5, 2026, the company said its next Black Card increases, in the second quarter of 2027, will be regional. A regional increase is diluted in the chain's totals. Under the rule we froze, it can produce no verdict either way.

The card on the sign

Planet Fitness was founded in 1992 in Dover, New Hampshire. It started as the brothers Michael and Marc Grondahl's small-town gym. Chris Rondeau joined them at the front desk in 1993. As chief executive he told the story in a letter in the 2015 prospectus. At first the gym was "a place where the fit got fitter." Then they asked, "Why does 80% of the population not belong to a gym?" The answer, he wrote, was that "first-time and occasional gym users were intimidated" by the regulars. Through the 1990s they changed the gym for them. Planet Fitness, the letter says, became the "Judgement Free Zone" in the company's spelling. It is a chain of 2,962 gyms, about nine in ten of them run by franchisees. It had 1,014 when it first reported as a public company in 2015. The beginner and the casual gym goer are, in the company's words, "traditionally our sweet spot."

It sells two memberships. The Classic Card costs $15 a month and buys one club. The Black Card costs $24.99 and adds every club in the system, a guest and the massage chairs. A new price applies only to people who join after it. Most of the marketing carries the Classic price. Most of the people who answer it buy the other card.

The Black Card cost $19.99 for fifteen years. Then came three steps: to $21.99 in 2017, $22.99 in 2019 and $24.99 in 2022. In June 2024 the Classic Card went from $10 to $15.

A ruler marked in tenths of a million

The company reports its member count each quarter to the nearest 0.1 million. It does not report how many people joined or how many cancelled. All an outsider can see is net additions, joins minus cancellations.

On that ruler the three Black Card increases show no fall in net additions. But the ruler is coarse. The 50 percent Classic increase of 2024, which the company itself expected to cost members, left net additions in its one clean quarter 0.2 million below the year before. That is too little to tell from the rounding. The counts cannot see a fall smaller than 0.1 to 0.2 million a quarter. In 2025 that was between 3.3 and 9.6 percent of a quarter's joins, which we estimate as net additions plus cancellations. A Black Card rise that cost the chain one joiner in twenty would not register.

Net new members by quarterMillions, from the rounded member counts in each quarter's releaseCOVID-1.0-0.50+0.5+1.0+1.5Quarter (first quarter of each even year labeled)'16'18'20'22'24'26Black $21.99Black $22.99Black $24.99Classic $15
Net new members each quarter, from the member counts Planet Fitness reports rounded to a tenth of a million, so each bar is uncertain by about 0.1 million either way. First quarters (lighter) carry the year. The dashed lines mark each disclosed price change, all for new joins only. Source: Planet Fitness quarterly releases and filings, 2015 to 2026; COVID quarters shaded and left out of the test's bands.

[chart: net-adds]

The other public number is Black Card penetration, the share of all members who hold the card: about 62 percent through 2023, about 68 percent at the end of June 2026. Management's explanation for the climb is the gap between the two prices, which the Classic increase narrowed from $14.99 to $9.99. Penetration is where a move down to the Classic Card would show.

Share of members on the Black CardPercent at quarter end, as stated on the calls (latest restated value)COVID56%58%60%62%64%66%68%Quarter (first quarter of each even year labeled)'16'18'20'22'24'26Black $21.99Black $22.99Black $24.99Classic $1567.9%
The share of members on the Black Card at each quarter end, from the earnings calls, using the latest figure where the company restated one; the band shows the rounding. The share slipped for several quarters after the 2022 Black Card rise, a stretch that cannot be read cleanly because other changes landed at the same time, and climbed after the Classic rise narrowed the gap between the tiers. Source: Planet Fitness earnings calls and annual reports, 2015 to 2026.

[chart: penetration]

Two lines

The tool for a two-price menu is a 1978 paper by Michael Mussa and Sherwin Rosen. A seller who cannot tell its customers apart offers two versions at two prices and lets each customer choose. Vista Research keeps a library of decision models, and the entry built on the paper is called Let them sort themselves. Intel sorted its buyers that way with a chip in 1991. Its 486SX was a 486DX with the math coprocessor disabled. It cost more to make and sold for $333 against $588, so that the buyer who needed the arithmetic would pay for it.

The question for a gym is who moves when the price of the better version rises.

Give each prospect two numbers: what the club itself is worth to her each month, and what the Black Card's extras are worth on top. A higher Black Card price can move two groups, two lines of people.

The first would pay $15 for the club anyway. They took the Black Card because the extras were worth the $9.99 difference. At a wider difference some of them take the Classic Card instead. Nobody leaves. We call that the trade-up line.

The second would not pay $15 for the club alone. The club and the extras together were worth $24.99 to them, so the Black Card was the only door they were going to use. A higher price closes it. We call that the join line.

The model says when the join line is empty. Someone on it values the club at less than $15 and the club and extras together at $24.99. So the extras are worth more than $9.99 to her. Now suppose the people who value the club most also value the extras most. Then everyone who would pay $15 for the club values the extras at more than $9.99 too, and nobody buys the Classic Card. But people do buy it. So nobody stands on the join line. The Classic price decides who comes in, and the Black price only decides who trades up. That is the arithmetic behind the November sentence.

A free first month is one way to fill the join line. This part is our reading, since the offer's terms beyond its name are not disclosed. A beginner has never used a second club or brought a friend, so she does not know what the extras are worth to her. Finding out would cost $24.99 for a month at a club she doubts is worth even $15, so she stays home. A free month lets her find out for nothing. Suppose the club is worth $12 a month to her, and after a month she finds the extras worth $14. Together that is $26. She stays at $24.99. The Classic Card at $15 cannot win her. At $29.99 she is gone.

Call her a Black-door joiner. The hypothesis is a claim about how many of her there are.

The model, in one box

In words first. A prospect takes the card that leaves her more after its price. She stays home if neither leaves her anything.

Black Card if v + w - pB >= max(v - pC, 0); Classic Card if v - pC >= 0 and v - pC > v + w - pB; otherwise stay home

A higher Black Card price then costs two things. Lost joins are the joiners, times the share who came through the Black door, times the share of those the rise turns away. Lost trade-ups are the other joiners, times the share it moves down.

lost joins = N x s x e; lost trade-ups = N x (1 - s) x t

An illustration, every number assumed. Take 1,000 joiners, 100 of them Black-door joiners and 900 ordinary. Six in ten of the ordinary ones take the Black Card, as the company says its joiners do. A $5 rise moves one in three of those buyers down to the Classic Card. That is one ordinary joiner in five, about 180 trade-ups. The rise sends one Black-door joiner in three home, about 33 joins.

One limit, and it is a large one. Net additions swing from one year to the next with no price change at all. The test below treats any move within twice the usual swing as noise. For two quarters of net additions, that band is 0.43 million members.

In our model, lost joins alone push net additions outside the band only if a rise turns away more than 8.4 percent of all joiners, about one in twelve. In the illustration it turns away one Black-door joiner in three. So the group would have to be about three times that: at least a quarter of all joiners, 25.1 percent.

That is a detection threshold, not an estimate of the group's size. The illustration's group of 10 percent would cost real joins and could make the May sentence right. But 33 joins in 1,000 is well short of one in twelve, and the trade-ups beside them are more than five times as many. The test would show the pattern of trade-up alone. Neither that pattern nor a result inside the noise can prove that no customers were lost.

Three other explanations

The consumer. Management cited it when it paused, and today it is the strongest. "While we conducted extensive testing over the past couple of years to support a potential Black Card price increase, the consumer and economic backdrop have shifted," Ms. Keating said in May. The quarter behind the pause brought "more than 700,000" net new members, against about 900,000 a year earlier, and the Black Card price had not moved. The company named four causes: marketing that missed beginners, regional competition, weather and household budgets. If this is the cause, joins are weak on both cards alike, in markets where no price changed, and the Black Card's share of joiners is undisturbed.

The size of the step. The earlier increases were $1 or $2: rises of 10.0, 4.5 and 8.7 percent. This one is $5, or 20.0 percent, twice the largest. It may reach buyers no small step touched, with or without a free month. If so, a $2 increase today would behave as the old ones did. Our hypothesis says even a small step now costs some joins.

The Classic Card. "The wrinkle and the difference now is that we've had the Classic Card price increase," Jay Stasz, then the CFO, said in November 2025. By the same model, a more expensive entry card can open a Black door with no free month. A prospect who valued the club at $12 would have taken the Classic Card at $10. At $15 her only door is the Black Card, if the extras are worth at least $12.99 to her. If this is the cause, Black-door joiners have arrived in every month since June 2024, not only in the months of the free offer.

How do they weigh? The second and third agree with us that the old history is a poor guide to this increase. They predict the same reading of the test and differ about the cause. The first disagrees outright: as we state it, the history is sound and the season was bad. The public record does not let us rank our reading above it.

A couple of markets

Two questions would help us rank them. When a premium price rose in some clubs and not in others, what happened to new joins where it rose? And to the share of joiners choosing the premium tier? A club operator who has been through such a change could answer both from past experience.

The evidence that would come closest to settling this already exists, club by club. Since 2024 the company has tested higher Black Card prices in some of its markets. By August 2025 the card cost $29.99 in New York and Charlotte. In June 2026 Ms. Keating said, "We do have some markets that are at $29.99, a couple of them."

The company has said cancellations did not differ materially at the higher price. It has not said what joins did in those clubs against comparable clubs at $24.99. A weak consumer hits both sets of clubs alike. A price effect shows only where the price rose. A count of who came in through the free month would say whether the rise turned Black-door joiners away or only moved ordinary joiners down.

The regional increases planned for 2027 add a catch. The decision, Ms. Keating said in announcing them, "is supported by the modernization of the Black Card Spa with a greater focus on recovery." Where a higher price arrives with an upgraded Black Card Spa, the comparison must account for what members get for the money.

Likely, we can get some of it from primary research, which is what Vista is all about. Franchise operators and their finance and marketing leads have seen joins respond to prices in their own clubs. So have former Planet Fitness pricing and marketing people. Pricing economists know what to expect. We will ask them the two questions above and three more. Of the people who joined through a free trial of a premium tier, what share would not have joined on the basic tier? How many people join a low-price club in a quarter, before cancellations? Do the people who value the basic membership least also value the premium extras least? All five ask about past and general experience only: no current employees of the company, nothing confidential, nothing about its current tests.

The experts inform the follow-up. They never decide the score.

The test

We froze the test on October 29, 2026, before any result existed. Its wording carries a fingerprint, a SHA-256 code that changes if one character does: be547db5e0834f2271fc87f61ecabd5c82d9a60a2bc7a5ae787ceea6cdef25bb.

It scores each change in the Black Card's monthly price for new joins. The company must announce it before reporting its fourth quarter of 2027, about February 2028, and it must take effect. The test reads two numbers over the first two full quarters after the change.

The first is net additions in those two quarters, less the same two quarters a year earlier. A fall can come from fewer joins or from more cancellations, and the number cannot say which. Its band is the 0.43 million above, with a two-year check at 0.46 million.

The second is Black Card penetration, the card's share of all members, at the end of the second quarter, less where two trends would have put it. The trends are a straight line and a curve that flattens, each fitted to the eight quarters before the change, and they must agree. Penetration counts every member, so a fall can come from existing members switching down as well as from new joiners choosing the Classic Card. Its band is 1.07 points.

The labels were written around management's November sentence, not our hypothesis. Each is defined by a pattern in the two numbers, and a pattern does not show its cause. CONFIRMED is the pattern written for that sentence: net additions within 0.43 million of the year before, and penetration more than 1.07 points below both trends. FALSIFIED is the pattern written against it: net additions more than 0.43 million below the year before, and penetration below both trends by any amount. It is the reading our hypothesis predicts. CANNOT TELL is anything else, with its reason named. A regional change, like those planned for 2027, can score no better.

FALSIFIED would not by itself prove the free month's door. A weak season, or a rise in cancellations, could produce the same pattern, and the void rules guard against neither. Only a comparison of markets, where the price rose against where it did not, would separate the door from a slump.

The test is VOID if no qualifying change comes before the fourth-quarter 2027 results. It is VOID if the change quarter or either measured quarter also brings a national change in the Classic price or the annual fee, or clubs closed by public order. So too a new national campaign, or a national promotion of either card's monthly price that did not run a year earlier. A price cut is scored as the mirror image.

We think there is about a 20 percent chance that the test, if it reaches a verdict, reads FALSIFIED, the reading our hypothesis predicts. That is our estimate of the test, not a forecast of Planet Fitness's membership or its share price.

For it: the company paused the national increase and cited joins, most joiners now take the Black Card, and the step it paused was twice the largest before it.

Against it: the threshold above. In our illustration, a Black-door group smaller than a quarter of all joiners reads CONFIRMED. A national rise taken in a second quarter, after the peak season as the paused 2026 plan had it, is measured in the third and fourth quarters. The free month has run in March, so its door would not show. No earlier step shows a fall the counts can see. The likeliest result of any one price change is no verdict.

The best case we're wrong

A door is only a door if people walk through it, and the company's account of 2026 is of beginners not arriving. Black Card First Month Free ran again in March 2026, and join trends "remained below our plan." Asked in May about joiners new to gyms, the interim CFO said their share had been "down a little bit" for a couple of quarters. A large Black door for beginners would not predict that. Nor is the old history free of promotions. The company ran them on the Black Card in 2019 and 2021, on terms not on record. If the free month changed nothing those had not, 20 percent is generous.

Other menus

Any seller with a cheap tier and an expensive one faces the same two lines when it raises the top price. A history of increases measured on people who had already joined says little once the front door has changed.

Spotify has a free tier with ads and a paid one, Premium. The U.S. price of Premium Individual went from $9.99 to $10.99 in July 2023, to $11.99 in June 2024 and to $12.99 in January 2026. In February co-CEO Alex Norström told investors, "Churn is low and came in according to our expectations." Churn counts members who leave. Spotify's own page offers a newcomer Premium at "$0 for 1 month, then $12.99 per month after." What the price does at that door is a separate count.

Amazon raised Prime's U.S. annual fee to $99 in 2014, to $119 in 2018 and to $139 in 2022, and offers a free trial. Amazon expected some members to quit, its CFO, Brian Olsavsky, said in 2022, but the loss "hasn't been large in the past." He also said past increases were hard to use as a gauge, since benefits and membership had changed.

YouTube sells a cheaper Premium Lite below Premium, offers trials to first-time members and raised the Premium price in 2026.

None of this judges those companies. When a seller cites its history of premium price increases, ask whether a free trial of the premium version has arrived since.

A month after the pause, at a conference, Ms. Keating gave the reason in a sentence I like better than the November one or the May ones: "we just didn't think it was prudent to then raise the price of the thing that most people take." The company records every join and every cancellation daily, and much of the answer is in its point-of-sale system. From outside, the question stays open. How many of the people who take it would have stayed home without it?

Tell us where we're wrong

If you have run clubs or set prices at a low-price gym chain, or you study how price menus sort buyers, your past experience may hold a term in the box that we do not. We ask for general experience only, never anything confidential. Write to director@vistaresearch.ai. We print what we hear, dated, and the follow-up puts your answers into the formula.

Questions this hypothesis answers

Did Planet Fitness's past Black Card price increases cost it joins?

On its November 6, 2025 call, Planet Fitness said earlier Black Card increases were "not a headwind to join volume": fewer joiners chose the Black Card for a while, but just as many joined. On May 7, 2026, it paused the national rollout of a rise from $24.99 to $29.99 a month, saying price increases "create a near-term headwind to member joins."

How can both statements be true?

Our hypothesis, and it is only that, is that something changed after the history was made. In March 2025 the company ran Black Card First Month Free. Every earlier Black Card increase, in 2017, 2019 and 2022, came before it. A free first month may have turned the premium card from the thing members trade up to into the door beginners come in through, and a higher price at that door can cost joins, not just trade-ups.

How will Vista test it?

The test, frozen on October 29, 2026, scores the next change in the Black Card's monthly price that the company announces before its fourth-quarter 2027 results. It reads net additions over the first two full quarters after the change against the year before, and Black Card penetration against two trends. Each pattern has a label: CONFIRMED for management's November sentence, FALSIFIED for the pattern our hypothesis predicts, CANNOT TELL for anything else, and VOID under stated rules, including a regional change that can score no better than CANNOT TELL.

What are Vista's odds?

We think there is about a 20 percent chance that the test, if it reaches a verdict, reads FALSIFIED, the reading our hypothesis predicts. That is our estimate of the test, not a forecast of Planet Fitness's membership or its share price.

Where else does the same question apply?

Any seller with a cheap tier and an expensive one faces it when the top price rises. Spotify offers newcomers a free month of Premium and has raised the US price three times since 2023; Amazon offers a free trial of Prime and raised the fee in 2014, 2018 and 2022. A history of increases measured on people who had already joined says little once the front door has changed.

For the record

What was verified. Vista's AI research desk computed every figure about the company above in code from its filings and call transcripts, and every quotation was checked against the transcript or filing it came from. Not verified: the company's own posted transcripts, because its investor site refused automated requests; the terms of Black Card First Month Free beyond its name; and the illustration's numbers, which are assumptions.

How the figures were made. Member counts are the company's rounded statements in its earnings releases and quarterly reports, taken at face value; each net addition carries plus or minus 0.1 million of rounding and each year-earlier comparison 0.2 million. Black Card penetration is the latest restated figure for each quarter, from the calls and annual reports. Gross joins are our estimate: net additions plus cancellations at the 3.5 percent monthly attrition the company gave for the second quarter of 2026. The price history and its dates are the company's own sentences on its calls and in its annual reports. The illustration assumes 1,000 joiners, six in ten ordinary joiners taking the Black Card at the $9.99 gap, each group's surplus spread evenly over the same range, and a $5 rise; its shares follow from those assumptions, and on them lost joins outnumber lost trade-ups only once Black-door joiners pass 37.5 percent of joiners. The 25.1 percent threshold adds the frozen band of 0.43 million, a rise taking effect after the peak join season, and everything else on its seasonal path; reaching the first count the rounding can show would take 29.2 percent. The bands are twice the root mean square of each measure over the quarters with no price change, the penetration band carried to the second full quarter after a change. The frozen wording, the band derivation and the scoring rules are constants in model.py under the fingerprint printed above, refrozen on October 29, 2026 from the first freeze of the same day, 915e85f531b87586f756d53192b6c3be45807c844d0233cb175f90d7454c1ec3, which the program rebuilds and matches; only the penetration band moved. A scoring note dated November 11, 2026, written before any 2027 price change or figure existed and outside the fingerprint, changes no frozen word or band. It fixes two things. A change counts as national only if the company calls it national or system-wide, or discloses that it applies to every U.S. club; any other change is regional. And the event our 20 percent is attached to is that the test, if it reads CONFIRMED or FALSIFIED on a qualifying change, reads FALSIFIED. The two share prices are the closes the complaint states, which match the market record; no market price series is used. The transcripts are third-party hosts, mostly machine-generated; where two hosts differ by a word, the quotation follows the host whose text reads as spoken.

The questions and the box. Each question in "A couple of markets" stands for a term in the box: new joins where a premium price rose, e; the share of joiners choosing the premium tier there, t; joiners through a free trial who would not have joined on the basic tier, s; joins in a quarter before cancellations, N; and whether those who value the basic membership least also value the extras least, v and w.

Sources

Disclosures

This hypothesis is research, not investment advice. It states what the filings and models show under labeled assumptions; nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security, and the decision belongs to the reader. Russ W. Rosenzweig, Vista's founder, owns no shares of and holds no options on Planet Fitness, as of October 29, 2026. He owns shares of and holds options on Intel, which appears here only for a chip it sold in 1991. He owns shares of and holds options on Amazon and on Alphabet, YouTube's parent, and owns no shares of and holds no options on Spotify; all three appear here only as examples of a pricing question, and for them shares are as of October 4, 2026 and options as of November 12, 2026. Holdings through mutual funds and exchange-traded funds are not counted. The lawsuit named near the top is the occasion of the question and nothing more: this hypothesis takes no view of its merits or its outcome, says nothing about what any person knew or when, and characterizes no party or counsel. How this hypothesis was made: written by Russ W. Rosenzweig with Vista's AI research desk. The facts were gathered from the company's filings on EDGAR and the transcripts of 46 earnings calls and one investor conference, saved in full, the ten from 2015 to the third quarter of 2017 from a transcript library, every quotation was checked against the transcript or filing it came from, the models were built and every figure computed in code with its test frozen before any result exists, and the draft was fact-checked and read for plainness before I read it. I read it and listened to it before it was published. Why I write with AI. Why I publish these.