VISTA·RESEARCH™
How it worksThe LibraryResearchHeritageAboutTalk to the Desk
Hypothesis · Pentair, Hayward and the pool dealers

Inventory or Exodus

By Russ W. Rosenzweig · Vista Research · 12 November 2026 · Why I write with AI

For a while at Round Table Group, I had a very particular idea of the lawyer I wanted to hear from. The lawyer would be at an elite firm, with one of its biggest disputes and a need for a famed professor from a leading university. A smaller matter might need only a doctor or a practitioner, somebody who did the work for a living. We began turning those matters away. I had studied economics at Northwestern and gone to business school at Chicago. I could explain this decision beautifully, in arrogant academic terminology: Pareto optimization.

A competitor, as I remember it, boasted of being "whale hunters", focused only on the top lawyers and matters. We wanted whales too, and it was a terrible idea. The matters we had been throwing back drew much less competition and were more likely to end with an expert actually retained. So we built a division for them, raised prices a little and lowered our costs. About half our business is there now, and that division is more profitable than the complex side. We went out for whales and learned to love the catch we used to throw back.

I thought of those matters again when I came across the public complaint of City of Warren General Retirement Health, Life and Disability Benefits Plan and Trust v. Pentair plc, filed August 12, 2026, in federal court in Minnesota. I read complaints for fun. My day job at Round Table Group is helping trial lawyers find expert witnesses, and at Vista Research we bring experts to bear on questions that investors and executives are trying to answer. As of this writing, Round Table Group is not working on this case. The lawsuit is the occasion and not my subject, and I take no view of it. The business facts here come from the companies' own filings, releases and calls.

Pentair is the publicly traded maker of the pumps, filters and heaters behind a great many American backyard pools. In the middle of July, of all months, it warned that its pool sales were falling short, and its shares lost about 15 percent in a day. Its chief executive has since said that the way it carried out a program aimed at its most valuable customers cost it some share among the smaller ones. I expected to find the missing dealers in the numbers. What I found first was a warehouse.

The answer, Deane, is yes

Two weeks after the July warning, during the earnings call of July 28, Deane Dray of RBC asked whether the program's disruptions had brought fallout on the customer side. John L. Stauch, Pentair's chief executive, answered: "The answer, Deane, is yes." He said the trouble was not the tool but the way Pentair had applied it. He thought Pentair had "made some assumptions on some of the smaller distributors, buying groups, and small dealers that are independent and don't necessarily buy from the two largest distributors". He went on: "Those actions did create disruptions and some of the lost share that we had alluded to in the aftermarket side of our business." The aftermarket is the equipment for pools already built.

By the call of October 27, Stauch was plainer. Jeff Reive of RBC Capital asked how Pentair would keep the program's discipline. Stauch said the tool had probably been misused, and then he drew a line. "You do not fire customers ever. Customers choose to be with you or leave you based upon the set of parameters that you give them." Pentair had just announced a new chief executive for its Pool business, Josh Cowley, and a team was calling the independent accounts, "reminding them that we want them back". Some of them, Stauch said, were "smarting on our desire to ask them to go to distribution and their choice not to".

The tool had a name I knew well. 80/20. A few customers, 20 percent in the shorthand, bring most of the results, 80 percent, so they get most of your attention. Stauch had named it himself in July, right after his yes: "It's not 80/20 as a tool. It's the way you implement 80/20." On the October call he said: "First of all, 80/20 is a very good tool, and I am a huge fan of the tool." About twenty years ago, "80/20ing your business" was in vogue among people I knew in the Entrepreneurs' Organization and the Young Presidents' Organization. In time I applied it to the company I knew best, and began "firing" every client but the whales. I could have saved myself considerable trouble by asking a second question. Who would be glad to get the customers I was turning away?

The idea behind the name is older than Pentair. Around the turn of the twentieth century the economist Vilfredo Pareto studied the unequal distribution of wealth and income and fitted a mathematical law to it. Half a century later Joseph M. Juran, preparing the first Quality Control Handbook (1951), needed a short name for what he came to call the "vital few and trivial many", and took Pareto's. He later confessed in print, in a paper titled "The Non-Pareto Principle; Mea Culpa", that he "had mistakenly applied the wrong name to the principle". He added: "Had I been structured along different lines, assuredly I would have called it the Juran principle." Illinois Tool Works, which we studied to death in business school, made the rule a system, and its annual report says the process now runs in every business it owns. Pentair's annual report says it "implemented 80/20 guiding principles" in 2025.

Fifteen percent in a day

The warning had come in a press release dated July 14, 2026. Distributors, Pentair said, were cutting their stocks of its pool equipment harder than it had expected. It reckoned the drawdown would take about $250 million out of Pool sales and $155 million out of Pool segment income, the profit its pool business reports, for the year. The same release cut the whole company's outlook and announced the departure of its chief financial officer. "We believe these headwinds are temporary", Stauch said. The shares fell anyway, from a close of $75.68 on July 14 to $64.33 on July 15, about 15 percent in a day.

Pentair did not start out in pools. In 1966, by the company's own account, "five men intent on manufacturing high-altitude balloons founded a company in suburban St. Paul, Minnesota". They named it from the Greek "penta", for the five of them, and "air", for what they planned to make. What followed, in the company's telling, ran "from plastic canoe manufacturing to computer software, to leather footwear", then to paper mills, then to tools, and at last to water. I can't quite tell whether this is a company that masterfully reinvents itself over the long arc of time or one that, like my nephews, keeps trying new things until it finds itself.

In 2018 it separated its electrical business, which became nVent Electric. Its shares trade on the New York Stock Exchange as PNR. It is run from Golden Valley, Minnesota, by Stauch, chief executive since 2018 and chief financial officer from 2007 until then.

A bad year in pools is a bad year for Pentair. The Pool segment was about 38 percent of 2025 sales and the most profitable of its three businesses, with $527 million of segment income, 46 percent of the total.

A distributor who buys fewer pumps because the warehouse is full and a dealer who buys a different brand produce the same disappointing number at Pentair. One of those problems ends when the stock runs down. The other requires somebody to change his mind.

A fall like July's reads as fear of the second kind, that the customers themselves had gone. The release carried other news too, so nobody can say how much of the fall was that fear. Here is our reading, and it is never a call on the stock. By Pentair's own figures, the whole fall in shipments was shelves. To the extent the market priced lost customers in July, part of that fear may have been overblown. The part that may not be is smaller, and still open.

What went into the warehouse

A pump leaves Pentair in November and spends the winter on a distributor's pallet before a pool dealer takes it away in April. The first transaction is a shipment. Pentair calls the second one sell-through. Between the two, the pump has had a quiet winter and two accountants have had something to think about.

Pentair's Pool segment sold $1,558.8 million in 2025, up 8.5 percent. In 2026 its sales fell 42.3 percent in the second quarter and 17.7 percent in the third, each from a year before. Through September they were down 20.6 percent. During those same nine months Pool Corporation, the world's largest wholesale distributor of pool supplies, grew its equipment sales, all brands together, by about 5 percent. I own shares of Pool Corporation.

During the October 27 call, Stauch gave the number the rest stands on. Pentair estimates that sell-through "will be $1.45 billion up 2% to 3% versus 2025". Robert W. Hau, who became chief financial officer on November 1, said the distributors would end the year holding about $180 million less Pentair equipment than a year before.

Take 2.5 percent, the midpoint of Stauch's range, and work backward. Distributors resold about $1,415 million of Pentair equipment in 2025. Pentair shipped about $1,559 million. About $144 million went onto the shelves. In 2026 the figures run the other way. Pentair expects about $1,270 million of Pool sales against $1,450 million of sell-through. About $180 million comes off the shelves, which is Hau's figure. After all that movement, the distributors end the two years holding only about $35 million less than they began with.

Now the fall itself. Add the $144 million of stocking up that did not repeat to the $180 million drawdown that followed it. That takes about $324 million out of shipments. Give back the growth in sell-through, which also happens to be about $35 million, and you have the $288 million fall, within rounding. By Pentair's own estimates, inventory is about 112 percent of the fall. The shelves explain all of it and more, because sell-through grew. In dollars, more was going out of the warehouse to dealers. Much less was coming in from Pentair.

04008001,2001,600$ millions1,5591,4151,2701,4501,4501,45020252026 (forecast)2027 (Pentair illustration)Pool shipments (reported sales)Sell-through to the trade
Pentair Pool shipments against sell-through, what its distributors and other resellers sold on to dealers, builders and service companies, in $ millions. Sell-through and the 2026 shipment figures are Pentair's own estimates, from its October 27, 2026, call; the 2027 bars are its illustration of flat sell-through, not a forecast; 2025 sell-through is implied by its "up 2% to 3%". The fall in 2026 shipments is inventory; sell-through rose in dollars.

A swing like that has a name. In 1958 Jay Forrester described a supply chain in which a small change in retail demand produced wild swings in factory output, entirely because of delays in the ordering rules. In the beer distribution game, which John Sterman analyzed in 1989, intelligent people reproduced the swings every time. By 1997, when Lee, Padmanabhan and Whang traced its causes, it was called the bullwhip effect. Vista's Decision Library, our catalog of decision methods, keeps it under system dynamics. Pentair's two years have that shape. By its own estimates for 2026, what distributors resell will rise 2 to 3 percent while its Pool sales fall 18 to 19 percent. The bullwhip describes the size of the swing and nothing else.

That settles the arithmetic, if management's sell-through estimate is right. It leaves the team calling the dealers exactly where it was. A company can sell more and lose customers to a rival in the same year.

What a shipment cannot tell you

So the warehouse answers one question and sharpens another. Did the customers leave? Pentair's Pool segment earned nearly half of the company's segment income in 2025. Empty shelves fill back up. Customers who leave don't, and every year they stay gone, the gap compounds.

Pentair's shipments cannot answer it. In a maker's sales, an emptied shelf and a departed customer are the same missing order. What the channel resold can help tell them apart, but only set beside a comparable rival's, with each company's price taken out and the rule frozen before either reports. As far as we can find, no one has published that test for Pentair. So we wrote one.

The question travels. A restaurant owner who sees fewer tables in August can't tell from her register whether her regulars are on vacation or eating across the street. She can tell by walking across the street. Wherever a company calls a sales drop destocking, ask for sell-through, find a rival that sells through the same channel, take price out, and read the gap once the shelves are back to normal. Companies as big as Pentair and far bigger have faced it, with different answers.

Nike, under a push to sell direct, pulled its product from many retailers, and rivals such as On and Hoka gained shelf space. (I own shares of Nike and of Deckers Outdoor, Hoka's owner.) Modern Retail reported in December 2023 that Foot Locker was cutting Nike's share of its sales while On sat in 420 of its stores and Hoka was being added to 50 more. "Order books are growing, and we are taking back shelf space", Nike's finance chief, Matthew Friend, said in March 2026. He also said sell-through was not yet where Nike wants it. Nike's problem was never a full warehouse. It was a shelf with someone else's shoes on it. That looks like the exodus case.

Generac looks like the other kind. In 2023 its installers and distributors held too many home standby generators, and its residential sales fell 46 percent in the first quarter and 44 percent in the second. "We're still under shipping the market in terms of overall end market demand", its chief executive, Aaron Jagdfeld, said on the third-quarter call. By the fourth quarter residential sales were rising again and activations, Generac's measure of generators installed at homes, set a quarterly record. That looks like the inventory case.

Inventory fixes itself: once the shelves empty, the orders come back. An exodus has to be won back, one dealer at a time. A shareholder should hope for inventory, and the way to tell the two apart is what the channel resells, set against a rival, with price taken out.

In tools that year, Stanley Black & Decker and Techtronic, the owner of Milwaukee, were both cutting their own inventories. Stanley's tools and outdoor organic revenue fell in the second half, on weaker outdoor and do-it-yourself demand by its own account. Milwaukee's sales grew 12.7 percent in local currency over the same months. Their product mixes differ, so that pairing is suggestive only. Vista asked a version of the question in Inquiry No. 19, "Late, or Gone", about Microvast and Photronics, two manufacturers that said their customers had only delayed. We are studying it again at Cogent Communications, where the question is whether demand for long-haul wavelengths that customers could not yet accept is deferred or lost.

The brand the dealer bought

Pool Corporation carries Hayward too. Hayward Holdings, of Charlotte, North Carolina, trades on the New York Stock Exchange as HAYW. By its own estimates it holds about 33 percent of the North American residential pool market and draws about 85 percent of its sales from the aftermarket. Pool Corporation is its largest customer. One customer was about 18 percent of all Pentair's sales in 2025, and older annual reports name that customer as Pool Corporation. A dealer can switch manufacturers without switching distributors.

Hayward's North American sales were up 9.7 percent through September. Set Pentair's 2.5 percent for the year against Hayward's 9.7 and the gap is about 7 points. That comparison is rough, a year of estimated sell-through against nine months of shipments. For the third quarter both companies spoke of sell-through. Stauch said Pentair's grew at a mid single digit rate. Hayward put its own in the high single digits. Like for like, the gap is about 3 points. A pool pump is not bought on impulse, and nobody owns a second one for the fun of it, so a gap of that size wants an explanation.

0%3%6%9%12%Pentair sell-through, 2026+2.5%Pentair sell-through, Q3mid single digitsPool Corp equipment, 9 monthsabout 5%Hayward out-the-door, Q3high single digitsHayward N. America, 9 months+9.7%growth over 2025, percent (bars for single digits drawn at 5 and 8)
Where the share question lives. With the destock set aside, Pentair's own sell-through grew about 2.5 percent in 2026, the distributor's equipment sales, all brands, about 5 percent in nine months, and Hayward's North American sales about 9.7 percent with channel stocks it calls balanced; in the third quarter alone, like for like, the gap was about 3 points. Sources: Pentair and Hayward Q3 2026 calls; Hayward and Pool Corp 10-Qs.

It would be satisfying to find three points' worth of dealers in that difference. First you have to ask what the pumps cost. Through September, price increases added about 7.8 points to the growth of Hayward's North American sales and about 4.7 to Pentair's Pool shipments. If Pentair's sell-through carried the same price as its shipments, the gap of 7.2 points splits into about 3.1 of price and about 4.1 left after price. By the same assumption, the third quarter's gap is nearly all price. A dealer can pay more for the same pump. So the gap left after price is the part that could be customers.

Hayward's equipment sits on shelves too. Its management said its distributors held low single digits more stock at the end of September than a year earlier, enough to explain part of the gap if that estimate is right. It had called its channel "balanced" in July, at a quarter end it later described as a "mid-single-digit percentage increase year-on-year". The two descriptions can sit comfortably together on an earnings call. They give different answers when we try to put a dollar figure on the shelves. So the filings narrow the inventory explanation. They do not rule it out.

What would count as catching up

In April 1992 New Jersey raised its minimum wage and neighboring eastern Pennsylvania did not. David Card and Alan Krueger surveyed fast-food restaurants in both states before the raise and again after it, counting the employees at each. I was fascinated to read it, because my first job was at a Burger King in Parsippany, New Jersey, flipping burgers on the grill for $3.35 an hour. They never trusted me at the register. The question was never what happened in New Jersey. It was what happened in New Jersey that did not also happen in Pennsylvania. We take no side on the minimum wage and borrow only the design, difference-in-differences, which our Library describes as before and after, with someone who did not get it. Hayward is our Pennsylvania. The design rests on one assumption, which economists call parallel trends: that Pentair and Hayward would have grown alike had nothing changed among the dealers. I will come to the trouble pools give it.

A destock leaves shipments above sell-through and then below, and no lasting gap against a rival once the shelves are back to normal. Lost customers leave sell-through growing slower than a rival's even after price is taken out, and the gap stays open.

Here is the hypothesis in full. In 2027, with shelves back to normal, Pentair's pool sell-through grows at least 3 percentage points faster than Hayward's North American pool sales, after an allowance for rounding and vague reporting, and not by price alone. G is Pentair's 2027 sell-through growth minus the growth of Hayward's North American pool sales, in percentage points. A minus sign means Pentair is behind. V, the price-adjusted growth gap, is G with each company's reported price contribution taken out.

G = (S_2027 / 1450 - 1) - (H_2027 / H_2026 - 1), in percentage points

V = G - (p_P - p_H)

The test is sealed. A code computed from its exact wording is printed in "The test in full", after the Sources, with the dates and reasons we tightened it before publication. It will be scored from the two companies' annual reports for 2027, due about February 2028, and it gives one of three scores. Recovered needs G at least 3 points ahead and V at least 1.5, each beyond an allowance T for what the companies leave vague about their shelves and their figures. Still behind is the mirror image. Everything else is cannot tell, including a lead that is only price and any result for which either company leaves out the price figure the test needs. The test never decides on dollar growth alone. Pentair winning its dealers back is one interpretation of a recovered score, never the verdict.

T is about 1.4 points when both companies state their figures and about 5 when both say only that their channels are balanced. It rests on assumptions that no filing establishes, about how much stock distributors hold and how much a word like "balanced", or silence, can hide. The 3-point line is likewise a judgment of what would matter, not a statistical threshold.

One worked case shows how strict the test is, and nine more are scored in "The test in full". Suppose Pentair wins back the whole 2026 volume gap at the prices each company has announced for 2027. Its lead after price, V, is 4.2 points. Its lead in dollars, G, is only about 2.7, because Hayward's larger price increases narrow it. The test says cannot tell.

A fourteen percent increase on flat sell-through

Pentair's own sketch of 2027, given during the October call, holds a number that is easy to get excited about. Suppose distributors sell through $1.45 billion in 2027, the same as the estimate for 2026, and shipments come back into line. Pentair's reported Pool sales rise about 14 percent while the distributors resell the same dollar value as the year before. Stauch said of the sketch: "Clearly, that is a starting point. We would expect to do better." The formal forecast is due in early February. Doing better is the whole question.

Scored against Hayward's outlook from its early buy, the trade's advance orders for the coming season, the flat sketch reads still behind for any T up to 4.1 points. Price starts Pentair behind as well. For 2027 it has announced increases of 3 to 4 percent, and Hayward mid single digits before discounts. That puts Pentair about 1.5 points behind in dollars before anyone buys another pump. History is no kinder. By the test's own benchmark, Pentair's growth beat Hayward's by 3 points or more only in 2022 and 2023, years Hayward's annual reports describe as distribution channel destocking. It trailed Hayward's by 2.4 points in 2024. We found no published consensus of analysts' forecasts for either segment to set beside ours. So if the test reaches a verdict, we think there is about a 15 percent chance it reads recovered. That is judgment, not computation. The likeliest result of all is cannot tell.

Does it matter? The line itself is small. Three points of growth on $1.45 billion is $43.5 million of sales a year. At the 30 percent return on sales that Pentair expects from Pool in 2027, that is about $13 million of segment income. At the rate the second-quarter destock cost it, $105 million of segment income on $170 million of sales, it is about $27 million, an upper figure. Those are about 1 and 2.4 percent of Pentair's 2025 segment income of about $1.14 billion.

Now let the difference persist. Purely as illustration, growth 3 points a year slower for five years would leave Pool's sales about 14 percent lower than otherwise. At that 30 percent, the cost is about $61 million a year of segment income, 5.4 percent of Pentair's 2025 total. At 7.2 points a year, the same illustration gives sales about 31 percent lower and about $136 million a year, 11.9 percent. None of this is a price target or a recommendation. A small difference in a single year gets larger if it keeps showing up.

That is why I work so hard to get a few more lawyers to try Round Table Group, and a few more investment managers and executives to try Vista Research. In the world I live in, private companies are courted weekly by private equity firms and other would-be buyers. Three extra points of growth a year, kept up for five years, leave earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization about 16 percent higher, and at ten to thirteen times those earnings, God willing, that is the difference between writing these papers in the spare bedroom and writing them on a private plane, traveling in comfort with my wife, our new baby, the dog and the cat. So far, the spare bedroom.

Holders of Pentair, Hayward and Pool Corporation have an interest in the next set of orders. So do owners of any manufacturer that sells through distributors and dealers. A stock chart cannot tell them what the dealers will do.

The trouble with my favorite explanation

There is a hazard in recognizing your own mistakes in somebody else's accounts. You know how your story turned out. You can start to think you know how theirs will end. Round Table Group is one company, in a trade far from pools, notwithstanding that I love pools and was a well-paid lifeguard in New Jersey growing up, my upgrade and revenge from the Burger King gig. My company's history proves nothing about Pentair's dealers.

The inventory arithmetic stands on Pentair's $1.45 billion, which is its own estimate and not an audited figure. The test trusts the companies' words about their shelves. Suppose a word like "balanced" can hide a change of more than about 5.5 percent in the distributors' stock, and every such change runs the same way. Then a story with no difference in sell-through could score a recovery.

Then consider the kinds of pools the two companies serve. Pentair's focus, by Stauch's account, had been new pool builds, which Hayward says fell more than 20 percent in three years. That is the trouble pools give the design's one assumption. If one company sells more into new pools and the other more into pools already built, the two would not have grown alike even had every dealer stayed. By our model's assumptions, a difference of about 28 points in the share of sales tied to new construction would by itself reach the 3-point line. No filing measures it.

Pool Corporation's equipment sales grew only about 5 percent, so some of Hayward's gain may have come from brands other than Pentair. And dealers could stay switched while the two companies grow at the same rate, an exodus that leaves no mark where we said to look. We built a test that would rather say nothing than say something false, and it may take us at our word.

The next order

The annual reports will give the score about February 2028. A score tells us how the two companies' growth compares. To find out who came back, I would ask the people placing the orders, one question for each unknown in the formula.

Likely, we can get some of what is missing from primary research, which is what Vista is all about. I'd ask an independent pool dealer or the head of a buying group what share of independent accounts move to another brand when a maker asks them to buy through distribution. I'd ask how long it takes to win one back. The Clash set the dealer's question to music in 1982, in "Should I Stay or Should I Go".

I'd ask a former equipment sales leader at another maker how much of the gap between large suppliers' growth rates is price, and whether Hayward's growth comes from the share Pentair says it lost. I'd ask a former pool distribution manager who left in 2022 or later whether, after a destock, a warehouse refills to its old target or settles on a lower one. Those answers inform the follow-up. The published rule decides the score.

If you have bought, sold or distributed pool equipment and you can see where we are wrong, write to director@vistaresearch.ai. We print what we hear, with the date.

When one of the dealers Pentair has been calling needs another pump, the order may go to the same warehouse it always did. I'd like to see whose name is on the box.

Questions this hypothesis answers

How can Pentair's pool sales fall while what its distributors resell rises?

The distributors had bought ahead. By Pentair's estimates, they resold about $1,415 million of its pool equipment in 2025 while Pentair shipped about $1,559 million, so about $144 million went onto their shelves. In 2026 Pentair estimates they will resell about $1,450 million while it ships about $1,270 million, so about $180 million comes off. The stocking up that did not repeat, plus the drawdown, less about $35 million of growth in what was resold, accounts for the whole fall in shipments, about $288 million.

How will Vista tell whether Pentair lost pool dealers to Hayward?

By comparing growth once the shelves are back to normal, with price taken out. The test, frozen before publication and last refrozen on November 11, 2026, takes Pentair's 2027 pool sell-through growth over its stated 2026 sell-through of $1,450 million, minus the 2027 growth of Hayward's North American pool sales. It reads recovered only if Pentair is at least 3 points ahead, and at least 1.5 points ahead with each company's price contribution taken out, each beyond an allowance for vague reporting; still behind is the mirror image, and everything else is cannot tell. It is scored from both companies' annual reports for 2027, due about February 2028.

What chance does Vista give that Pentair wins its dealers back?

If the test reaches a verdict, we think there is about a 15 percent chance it reads recovered. That is judgment, not computation. Pentair's own sketch of 2027, flat sell-through, scores still behind against Hayward's outlook; its announced 2027 price increases of 3 to 4 percent trail Hayward's mid single digits; and by the test's benchmark its growth beat Hayward's by 3 points or more only in 2022 and 2023, years of distribution channel destocking. The likeliest result of all is cannot tell.

What was verified: Vista's AI research desk recomputed in code every figure derived from the filings, releases and transcripts named in the Sources, and a separate fact-check reopened each source. Not verified against an official record: the words spoken on the earnings calls, quoted from published transcripts and, for Generac, from a press report; what Foot Locker carried, as Modern Retail reported it; the share prices, from the complaint; and my account of Round Table Group and of myself, my own recollection.

Sources

The test in full

The seal. The test was first frozen on November 9, 2026, refrozen on November 10, and refrozen again on November 11, 2026, each time before publication and before either company reported again. The first outside review showed that the first version could score a price or channel effect as a win; the second showed that a missing price figure could still let price alone decide, that our allowances for the distributors' shelves rest on assumptions, and that our history of the gap used Hayward's whole company instead of the benchmark the test uses. The test is the dictionary FROZEN in model.py in the folder for this hypothesis; its SHA-256, a code computed over the dictionary written as JSON with keys sorted and no whitespace between elements, is 4b8172cbd426c8a055105eb60b60bb72c2aeacb1ac3ada779d24660870d8d8ae. The codes of the November 9 and November 10 versions, 45139f2944f842c82464834f4583f53b19e10df07f05e0779fdf51e8c5438d58 and 7168699dbded7ebc2cdcd9386a60a4b1a6bca6fb249b6f97799aa7d0adb0d9f8, are kept on record, with their wording, in the same file. The full frozen wording, whose code is printed here, is kept in Vista's records and will be published with the score; until then a reader cannot recompute the code.

The measure. G is Pentair Pool's sell-through growth in fiscal 2027 over its stated 2026 sell-through of $1,450 million, minus the 2027 growth of Hayward's North American pool sales (North America segment net sales less the flow control product group). V is G minus the difference between the two companies' reported 2027 price contributions, Pentair's for Pool and Hayward's for North America. Both are scored from the fiscal 2027 Forms 10-K, about February 2028, with the fourth quarter releases and calls for what each company says about sell-through and its channel.

The labels. Relative growth recovered: G at least 3 points beyond the tolerance T, and V at least 1.5 points beyond T on the same side. Relative growth still behind: the mirror image, at minus 3 and minus 1.5. Cannot tell: everything else, including a G past its line whose volume reading is not, which means the gap is price, and any result for which either company leaves out its price contribution, gives it only for the whole company or only in words, or merges it with another effect: the test never scores dollar growth alone. G, V and T are rounded to 0.1 point before any comparison, and where a company describes its channel more than one way, the most specific statement counts.

The lines. Our 3-point line, and the 1.5-point line for V, are judgments of what would matter, not statistical thresholds. By the test's own benchmark, Pentair Pool's sales growth against the growth of Hayward's North American pool sales was plus 3.9 against minus 5.0 percent in 2022, minus 17.7 against minus 26.9 in 2023, plus 6.9 against plus 9.3 in 2024 and plus 8.5 against plus 7.9 in 2025: gaps of plus 8.9, plus 9.2, minus 2.4 and plus 0.7 points, with a standard deviation, the usual measure of spread, of 5.9. That is too wide, over too few years, to set a line by statistics. Three points of growth on Pentair's $1,450 million of sell-through is $43.5 million of sales a year.

The tolerance T, in points, is the sum of four terms.

  • Channel words. A channel change stated in dollars is taken out exactly, whatever its size. When a company describes its channel only in words, the test turns the words into an estimate of how much the distributors' stock changed, under assumptions that no filing establishes, and puts the margin of error into T: balanced, normal, healthy or steady, 0 plus or minus 3 percent of channel stock against a year earlier; low, mid or high single digits up or down, 2, 5 or 8 percent that way, plus or minus 1; double digits, 15 plus or minus 5; anything else, or nothing, 0 plus or minus 9 percent, the most we assume one brand's stock moves in a year without being stated. Channel stock is taken as 4.7 months of a year's sales, Pool Corporation's company-wide ratio at December 31, 2025, used only as a scale, so 1 percent of stock is 0.39 percent of sales, about $5.7 million for Pentair. For Pentair the words cover its channel at the end of 2027; for Hayward, at the end of both 2026 and 2027, because its base year is shipments too. A verdict that rests on these words rests on these assumptions.
  • Stated figures. Half the last unit of any stated figure ($1.45 billion carries $5 million, 0.34 point), half of any stated range, and plus or minus 1 for single-digit words.
  • Geography. 0.06 times the gap between Hayward's own 2027 growth in North America and in Europe & Rest of World, for the share of Pentair Pool sold in other currencies, about 6 percent at most.
  • Flow control. 1.0 if Hayward's 10-K stops separating it.

In dollars on Pentair's side, the 3-point band is $43.5 million. Under the assumed readings, a balanced channel allows $17.0 million either way, a stated single-digit change $5.7 million either way around its midpoint, and the widest reading, anything else or nothing, $51.1 million (3.52 points). T comes to about 1.4 points if Pentair states its sell-through to the nearest $10 million and Hayward states its full-year sell-through growth as a whole percent; about 3.0 if Hayward gives only words; about 5.0 if both give only "balanced"; about 8 if Hayward says nothing about its channel in either year.

What the readings carry. The record does not establish the readings, and in places it strains them. Pool Corporation's own stock, all brands, was more than 3 percent above or below a year earlier at 5 of the last 7 quarter ends, from minus 3.2 to plus 13.7 percent. Hayward called its channel "balanced" in its release of July 29, 2026, at a quarter end when, by its chief executive on the October 28 call, it stood at a "mid-single-digit percentage increase year-on-year". Pentair's own channel, by its own figures, moved about 26 percent of a 4.7-month stock in 2025 and about 32 percent in 2026. If "balanced" can hide a change of more than about 5.5 percent in the distributors' stock and every such change runs the same way, a story with no difference in sell-through could score a recovery. The 2026 inventory arithmetic does not depend on the readings, because Pentair stated its figures as numbers, not channel words: inventory is about 112 percent of the fall in shipments, 110 to 115 percent across Pentair's stated ranges, and at least 77 percent even if its channel figures were off by twice the widest reading.

Fallbacks. Pentair's 2027 figure, in order: stated 2027 Pool sell-through in dollars; Pool net sales less a stated dollar channel change; stated sell-through growth in percent; otherwise Pool net sales under the channel words rule. A 2026 actual that Pentair states later replaces the $1,450 million. For Hayward, a stated full-year 2027 North America or U.S. sell-through growth is used; otherwise its North America pool sales under the channel words rule. Acquisitions and divestitures reported in 2027 come out of each side's growth.

Untested and void. Untested: Hayward stops reporting North America (no substitute; its total sales are never used), or Pentair stops reporting a Pool segment. Void: a recast moving fiscal 2026 Pentair Pool or Hayward North America sales by more than 2 percent, or a deal adding or removing more than 5 percent of either in 2027.

Worked cases, each scored with every figure exact. Six cases show the scoring; list prices are each company's announced 2027 increases, and the early buy is the trade's advance orders for the coming season. Pentair's flat 2027 sketch against Hayward's early-buy outlook scores G at minus 7.1 and V at minus 5.6, still behind; a repeat of the 2026 volume gap at 2027 list prices scores G at minus 5.8 and V at minus 4.3, still behind; a Hayward lead that is all price, at 2026 prices, scores G at minus 3.2 and V at minus 0.1, cannot tell, because the gap is price; keeping pace in volume at 2027 list prices scores G at minus 1.5, cannot tell; winning back the 2026 volume gap scores G at plus 2.7 and V at plus 4.2, cannot tell; and winning back twice that gap scores G at plus 7.0 and V at plus 8.5, recovered. The two still-behind scores and the recovered score hold while T is at most 2.8 points; taken one at a time, the flat sketch stays still behind for any T up to 4.1 and twice the gap stays recovered for any T up to 4.0.

-10-5-30+3+5+10G, points: Pentair Pool sell-through growth minus Hayward North America pool growth, 2027relative growthstill behindcannottellrelative growthrecoveredPentair's flat 2027 sketch-7.1, still behind2026 volume gap, 2027 list prices-5.8, still behindHayward's lead all price, 2026 prices-3.2, cannot tell: all priceKeeps pace, 2027 list prices-1.5, cannot tellWins back the 2026 volume gap+2.7, cannot tellWins back twice that gap+7.0, recovered
The test refrozen on November 11, 2026, scored from both companies' fiscal 2027 10-Ks (about February 2028). G is Pentair Pool's 2027 sell-through growth over its stated 2026 sell-through of $1,450 million, minus the 2027 growth of Hayward's North American pool sales, flow control left out. A verdict needs G past 3 points by more than the tolerance for unmeasured channel moves, and the volume reading, G less the price gap, on the same side: a gap that is all price, like the third row's, scores cannot tell, and so does any result for which either company leaves out its price figure. Each verdict shown holds while the tolerance is at most 2.8 points; 2027 list prices are Pentair's 3 to 4 percent and Hayward's mid single digits before discounts.

Four more cases. A repeat of 2026 so far, Hayward's figures through September, prices and all: G minus 7.2, V minus 4.1, still behind for any T up to 2.6. The third quarter like for like, repeated: G minus 3.0, V minus 0.3, cannot tell. A lead of 8 points made entirely of price, with Pentair's price figure missing: cannot tell; both earlier versions of the test would have scored it a win. An unstated $43.5 million restock with Pentair saying "balanced": G plus 3.0 with T at 1.2, cannot tell; stated in dollars, G 0.0. The first version of the test scored that restock as a win both ways. Put another way, with Hayward's North American pool sales up about 7.1 percent, recovered needs Pentair's sell-through up at least 10.1 percent plus T, about 6.4 percent of volume, against its own flat sketch of about minus 3.4 percent of volume.

Disclosures

This hypothesis is research, not investment advice. It states what the filings, the public record and the models show under labeled assumptions; nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security, and the decision belongs to the reader. The lawsuit named near the top is the occasion of this hypothesis and not its subject: nothing here predicts or comments on its outcome, says whether any statement was true or false, or characterizes any party, lawyer or expert in it, and every business fact comes from the companies' own documents.

Russ W. Rosenzweig, Vista's founder, owns shares of Pool Corporation, the largest customer of both Pentair and Hayward, of Nike, and of Deckers Outdoor, the owner of Hoka, and holds no options on any of the three. He owns no shares of Pentair, Hayward, Illinois Tool Works, Cogent Communications, nVent Electric, Microvast, Photronics, Generac, Stanley Black & Decker, Techtronic, On Holding or DICK'S Sporting Goods, which now owns Foot Locker, and holds no options on any of them. Holdings through mutual funds and exchange-traded funds are not counted.

How this hypothesis was made: Written with the help of AI tools. The facts were gathered from the filings, releases and call transcripts named in the Sources, the model was built and every figure computed in code, the test was frozen and then, after two outside reviews, tightened and refrozen twice before publication, each public source was checked against its original, and the draft was fact-checked and read for plainness before I read it. I read it and listened to it before it was published. Why I write with AI. Why I publish these.